
The Stop the War Coalition has marked a grave and ongoing tragedy at the Cenotaph. But a far greater tragedy will go almost unnoticed.
Two hundred and four British soldiers have now died in George Bush and Tony Blair's senseless invasion of Afghanistan, along with nearly 800 of their US counterparts.
No-one can honestly tell you what they died for. First the war was to catch Osama bin Laden, then it was to bring democracy to Afghanistan, now it's to stop terrorist attacks being plotted there. No doubt another empty excuse will be along soon.
Every death in the service of this pointless, stupid, apparently never-ending war is a tragedy - and that includes the people fighting it.
Some of those 204 victims may have joined up to escape desperate poverty, as so many US soldiers do. Some may have sincerely believed that they were doing humanitarian work or defending their country, or they may simply have trusted their government not to lead them wrong.
If so they were misguided. But being misguided is not a capital crime. And surely it's the people who told the lies that should pay, not the people who believed them?
These soldiers deserve to be mourned and they deserve to be remembered.
But while the Stop the War Coalition names every one of these 204 men and women, we must not forget that there is a far grimmer list of victims whose names we will never know and whose numbers will never be counted.
But while the Stop the War Coalition names every one of these 204 men and women, we must not forget that there is a far grimmer list of victims whose names we will never know and whose numbers will never be counted.
That is, the innocent Afghan men, women and children who have lost their lives in the near-eight-year assault on their country.
"We don't do body counts," US General Tommy Franks once infamously said of that other great criminal war of the 21st century.
Despite Franks, through the efforts of independent researchers we know that around 650,000 Iraqis had been killed by Bush and Blair's invasion by 2006 - a figure that could now be as high as 1.3 million.
It's still hard to comprehend the scale of that massacre, a bloodbath which puts Bush and Blair alongside some of the most notorious mass murderers in history.
But we have no idea of the extent of their guilt. Because we have almost no idea how many
But we have no idea of the extent of their guilt. Because we have almost no idea how many
Afghan deaths they have on their blood-drenched hands.
The lowest credible estimate is about 19,000, including civilians, resistance fighters and troops killed in the initial invasion.
But then the lowest credible estimate for Iraq is about 100,000 civilians - far removed from the true scale of the horror.
Have 10,000 Afghan civilians been killed? A hundred thousand? We simply do not know.
And we can't trust anyone to tell us. Not the UN, which decided during the Israeli assault on Gaza that just about all adult males were "fighters" and hence not fit to be included in civilian casualties.
And we can't trust anyone to tell us. Not the UN, which decided during the Israeli assault on Gaza that just about all adult males were "fighters" and hence not fit to be included in civilian casualties.
Not the US, which can't tell the difference between a group of Taliban guerillas and a wedding party.
And not the Afghan government, which is hardly going to admit the scale of its own troops' role in killing civilians.
So it's no fault of the Stop the War Coalition that these uncounted, unnamed thousands couldn't also be mourned at today's ceremony.
At least soldier's wife Clare Glenton had the compassion to admit what the devious hypocrites in the Cabinet won't - that "there are no firm figures on the number of Afghan lives lost but in an unjustified conflict even one life lost is too many."
Which is why our troops must come home now, to end the meaningless killing on both sides of this meaningless war. And it's why we can only hope that one day Bush and Blair will face the justice they deserve - even if we can never name their victims or measure the full scale of their crimes. Original story
